RT ‘Why Me? What Did I Do Wrong?’: Carrie Underwood’s Silent Question After Her Third Loss—And the Unexpected Answer She Found Crying Beside Isaiah’s Bed

Carrie Underwood is known for her powerful voice and her unshakable faith. But between 2017 and 2018, the country music queen was waging a silent, deeply personal war. Three times, the dream of giving her son, Isaiah, a sibling was brutally extinguished by miscarriage. While the world focused on her recovery from a traumatic fall, her inner turmoil was far more painful: a crushing spiritual despair that led her to ask the question no one dares to utter: “Why me? What did I do wrong?”

This isn’t the story of a public figure maintaining her composure; it’s the untold story of a mother’s breaking point, a moment of profound anger and desperation, which ultimately led to the miraculous arrival of her “rainbow baby,” Jacob. The answer to her heartbreaking question wasn’t found in a church, but in a small, quiet moment, crying beside her sleeping son’s bed.

The Third Loss: A Question of Punishment

Discover more

Twinless

Online art courses

music

murals

NYC

Murals

Online movie streaming services

New York City

New York’s

Celebrity

The loss of the third pregnancy was the final straw. Carrie, a woman whose life was built on hard work and devotion, began to believe she was being punished. She confessed that her despair turned to anger, directed squarely at God. She couldn’t understand the cruel logic: She was blessed, she was faithful, she was ready. Why was this happening to her, repeatedly?

The emotional core of her pain was the question: “What did I do wrong?” This wasn’t a search for error; it was a desperate plea for a reason—any reason—to explain the unexplainable. This question stalked her, overshadowing her success and her recovery. The guilt was suffocating.

The Breakdown: Crying Beside Isaiah’s Bed

One night, after receiving the final, devastating news of the third loss, Carrie retreated to the safest place she knew: her oldest son Isaiah’s bedroom. She lay on the floor beside his bed, letting the tears flow. This wasn’t a formal prayer; it was a surrender. She repeated the mantra of her pain: “Why me, Lord? Why do you keep giving me something I can’t hold onto?”

As she wept, her eyes fell on Isaiah’s peaceful, perfect face. He was oblivious to his mother’s suffering, safe in his world. In that raw, silent room, something shifted. It was an unexpected moment of profound clarity—the answer to her question finally arrived, but not in the way she expected.

Carrie suddenly realized the true fight wasn’t against God or against her body; it was against her own relentless desire for total control.

The Unexpected Answer: Surrender, Not Struggle

The profound realization was this: she had been holding onto the idea of a perfect, scheduled life—a career trajectory, a perfect family, a perfect body—so tightly that she was agonizing over things inherently beyond her power. The answer to “What did I do wrong?” was, shockingly, “Nothing.”

She hadn’t done anything wrong. She just needed to stop trying to manage the entire universe. That moment, crying on the carpet, was her total surrender. She let go of the pain, the guilt, and the need to control the outcome. She realized that she had two blessings already—Isaiah and Mike—and everything else was simply out of her hands. She finally accepted that she was not in charge.

The very next Monday, after that night of profound release, the phone rang. The doctor confirmed that the last pregnancy, the one she was certain was lost, was thriving. It was the pregnancy that would become Jacob, her “rainbow baby.”

The Legacy of Hope and Healing

Carrie Underwood’s story is a testament to the powerful connection between mental and physical health. The miracle of Jacob didn’t happen when she was trying the hardest; it happened when she finally gave up the fight for control and accepted her helplessness.

Her willingness to share the darkest corners of her heart—the anger, the guilt, and the silent question—has given strength to millions of women. She turned her pain into art with the album Cry Pretty, making it clear that it’s okay for emotions to be ugly and uncontained. Carrie Underwood proves that sometimes, the greatest blessings arrive only after you have let go of the tight grip on your own destiny and allowed yourself the grace of being simply human.